WV State Police Crime Lab Excepting & Producing Bogus Reports – Prosecuting Attorney Billowing Out Smoke Screen

WV State Police Crime Lab Excepting & Producing Bogus Reportsanonymous

by Anonymous

The “RitchieRailRoad.com Website” is now under the control and direction of New Editor(s) who are focusing its resources and information of facts received from known and unknown allies to educate Property Owners and good folks in Ritchie County, West Virginia of transgression by Public Officials in Ritchie County.

A private analysis of alleged State Police Evidence must be reviewed which may just blow the lid off the Prosecutor’s and the State Police Corruption Ring.

This Draft Report is about who is involved with corruption within the walls of the Ritchie County Prosecutor’s Office THEN and NOW. “Then” being ex-Ritchie County Prosecutor, Judith A. McCullough who knowingly and willingly worked with the lower ranks of the West Virginia State Police, Harrisville Detachment where ex-prosecutor Judith McCullough is suspected of assisting Harrisville State Police, Troopers C. E. Boring, J. L. Brewer and C.S. Jackson with falsifying and manufacturing evidence which was at some point allegedly sent to the West Virginia State Police Crime Lab to falsely but Forensically declare a match in the October 30, 2012 State Police Burglary Case. We agree a match has been reported by the State Police Crime Lab. However, this match has been reported to us as a fabricated match. The West Virginia State Police Crime Lab is also suspected of doctoring the Date and Time of the assumed Case Submission Form (4230-10809) which again, was allegedly submitted to the WV State Police’s very own Crime Lab.

The RitchieRailRoad and the Ritchie County Investigation Team would like to provide some proven and documented facts of corruption committed by the West Virginia State Police Crime Lab, not just one instance of WV State Police Crime Lab misconduct but numerous counts of corruption, bad faith and malicious intent dealing with false and falsified reports, bogus testing and other criminal behavior committed by the WV State Police Crime Lab. Here it is:

The West Virginia State Police Crime Lab has a long record for intentionally falsifying and fabricating evidence against defendants. In recent years, a special commission convened by order of the West Virginia Supreme Court of Appeals investigated the West Virginia State Police Crime Laboratory. As a result of this investigation, the WV State Supreme Court ruled that more than 130 cases which involved information and evidence tested by the West Virginia State Police Crime Lab was NOT credible.

The quantity and quality of documentation required by laboratory quality assurance/quality control protocols should preclude the wholesale falsification of test results. However, this is clearly the WV State Police working for the WV State Police, the Good Ole Boy System if you want to call it that.

The West Virginia State Police are alleging that their very own State Police Crime Laboratory has made a DNA Profile Match with the DNA of David Carl Wine and William Willis Estep II. State Police claim that shortly after a B&E at the Ritchie County State Police Detachment, they collected swab swipe samples from an Evidence Room Door and other items at the Harrisville State Police Detachment that was breached by the perpetrator or perpetrator(s). In the same breath, the WV State Police Crime Lab seems to be claiming that there may not be any sample left for further testing. At this point it is not clear if the entire sample has been used up or not. This effectively means Mr. Wine and Mr. Estep will be denied the opportunity to have samples tested by an independent laboratory. The only clear conclusion that can be drawn from this information is that the West Virginia State Police are using their very own forensic lab to falsify DNA evidence against Wine and Estep.

Now, at this point we must tell our readers that Mr. William Willis Estep II, nearly two weeks after the alleged crime and shortly after being questioned by State Police where Mr. Estep was allegedly coerced with a bogus DNA match by State Police and further being promised a plea where the Judge could only sentence him to probation (binding plea) Mr. Estep did sign the probation plea with the same prosecutor who denied Mr. Estep full discovery which would have provided Mr. Estep with crucial evidence which proved Mr. Estep’s statement and plea was wrongfully coerced when the State Police and the Prosecutor withheld Video Evidence that show State Police approaching Mr. Estep in a threatening manner while in custody which was shortly before Mr. Estep gave what was reported by State Police as a full non-coerced confession. Now, either the West Virginia State Police did not tell the Prosecutor, Steven A. Jones about the Video evidence or the Prosecutor, Steven A. Jones has denied full discovery to Mr. Estep. That’s right; we are all wondering what else is the State Police and the Prosecutor’s Office concealing? …Misconduct at the West Virginia State Police Crime Lab?

The Ritchie County Investigation Team believes there is new technology that will not only prove that WV State Police DNA evidence against Wine and Estep was falsified, but also, independent investigating and testing will show how the falsified evidence was created and the procedures used by State Police to fraudulently submit the bogus samples on a bogus Date to the State Police Crime Lab. Further investigation will also give evidence of whom and how many individuals conspired to falsify and fabricate evidence against at least two of the Defendant’s in State Police Burglary case.

DNA Science of the current date only requires minuscule quantities of a DNA specimen for testing. However, the West Virginia State Police Crime Lab would want one to think all specimens were used up during their in-house testing. The testing procedures used by the WV State Police Crime Lab to test the samples, most certainly should have allow the preservation of sufficient DNA for independent Laboratory testing. Yes, this is very suspect… With that said, the timing of the alleged DNA testing is also suspect, as Mr. Wine and Mr. Estep are both convicted Felons and their DNA Profile was in the State’s DNA Data Base pursuant to their previous Felony convictions. Therefore, if State Police would have discovered and collected alleged samples from the crime scene they could have simply entered the DNA collected at the supposed crime scene into the Data Base and a match would have been discovered. However, State Police only submitted samples to their very own Crime Lab only after Mr. Wine and Mr. Estep were arrested and only after both men’s home and personal belonging were searched on two separate occasions. Yes, now you can draw your own conclusion from this information on how the West Virginia State Police and their Crime Lab came up with their samples and the so-called MATCH.

During the 1980s, and 90s and even today Prosecutors across West Virginia lined up to use the WV State Police Crime Lab to wrongfully convict innocent defendants based on false testimony and fabricated test results cooked up by State Police and their State Police Crime Lab. In nearly all cases, which involved false and fabricated test results, defense attorney’s failed to consult competent scientific experts to examine alleged evidence. Mr. Wine’s attorney, Mr. Wells Dillon is set to employ scientific experts to disprove the fabricated evidence of the WV State Police and their made to order Crime Lab results.

One has to reflect on the likelihood that numerous innocent persons are presently incarcerated because of Rogue State Police and the inadequacy of some defense attorneys.

In the case at hand, technology can be used within the existing legal framework to stop the injustice being committed by the NOW Prosecuting Attorney, Mr. Steven A. Jones and the West Virginia State Police.

The Corruption Flag is flying high in Ritchie County, West Virginia as Steven A. Jones and the West Virginia State Police have already got caught in wrongdoing not to mention denying full discovery and hiding exculpatory video evidence from the Defendants.


RitchieRailRoad.com Page Views 2,728 for Sunday May 18, 2014 – – Also, Comments are now always private.

RitchieRailRoad is now in its fourth month of publication reached its highest day for page views yesterday – Sunday the 18th day of May.

RitchieRailRoad.com highest day of Page Views 2,728 recorded on Sunday, May 18, 2014 

It appears that more and more people are interested in the corruption allegedly taking place in Central WV – in Ritchie County WV and within the lower ranks of the WV State Police.

Also, for those of you who have submitted information, we thank you!

All of the Commenter’s who have submitted comments in the recent past, please note that we after a 10-7 vote have suspended the ability to comment on this site. The sole reason for the suspension being to protect commenter’s from retaliation from the powers that be. However, please keep the information rolling in by way of our comment boxes which are now always private.


Proven Self Reported Criminal, William Willis Estep II Gets Spectacular Plea Bargain in exchange to Test-Ta-Lie in the Harrisville State Police Burglary Case.

As promised in an earlier article on the RitchieRailRoad Website we are providing the Spectacular Plea Bargain between the State of West Virginia and William Willis Estep II.

 The Ritchie County Prosecutor’s Office has released the terms of a plea agreement between the State and Mr. William Willis Estep II regarding the Harrisville State Police Detachment being allegedly burglarized back in October 2012.

Rather than us giving you folk’s written statements about the Spectacular Plea Bargain or just our thoughts on the Plea Bargain, the Ritchie County Investigation Team that has been working to uncover Judicial Corruption in Ritchie County has unanimously requested that the RitchieRailRoad Post a Digital Copy of the Plea Agreement in its entirety. Therefore, the Digital Copy of the Plea Agreement is as follows:




Members of both the RitchieRailRoad Staff and the Ritchie County Investigation Team (17 individuals’ total) all feel the Plea Agreement signed on September 25, 2013 by Prosecutor Steven A. Jones, Attorney Jay Gerber and Defendant William Willis Estep II was executed with Malicious Intent and Bad Faith.

Mr. Estep seemed to have been caught red handed. However, upon evidence of crime being found and seized in Mr. Estep’s apartment during a police search shortly after the Harrisville State Police burglary, Mr. Estep made incriminating statements of not only the State Police Burglary but numerous other alleged self reported crimes during Two and 1/2 hours of questioning after police placed Mr. Estep in custody but prior to any Miranda warning being issued by State Police to Mr. Estep.

Video Evidence show Mr. Estep being placed in custody shortly before 10:00 p.m. and being questioned before the police documented Miranda Rights Form was signed by Mr. Estep at 12:38 a.m.

Information in the above two paragraphs is additional evidence that the Ritchie County Prosecuting Attorney has been acting with Malicious Intent and Bad Faith from the day he took over the case from ex-Ritchie County Prosecutor Judi McCullough.

Documents provided through discovery give clear evidence that Prosecutor Jones and the West Virginia State Police are acting in Bad Faith for refusing to arrest William Willis Estep for all the self reported felony crime he claims to have committed. Mr. Estep is clearly a “Blamer” who is trying to avoid facing serious ramifications for his lone criminal actions by pointing the finger at other persons who State Police want convicted.

* * There has been a sentence edited or removed HERE on this line. – – editors

It is calculated from Court Documents that Mr. Estep has allegedly committed at least 15 Felony Crimes. Anyone who would possibly be facing so much time in prison even if innocent would gladly accept the Bad Faith Plea Agreement which is indeed a spectacular agreement only allowing Ritchie County Judge, Timothy L. Sweeney to sentence Mr. Estep to Probation in exchange for Test-ta-lying in the case.

Here are Six (6) Special Investigation Notes from The Ritchie County Investigation Team.

1. When Mr. Estep was first questioned by State Police during the beginning of the Search of Mr. Estep’s apartment, Mr. Estep denied knowing anything about the Break-in at the Harrisville State Police Detachment or any other crime.

2. When State Police turned up evidence of crime during the search of Mr. Estep’s apartment Mr. Estep knew his lone crime spree was over. Mr. Estep must have been feeling that he was going to jail for a long time if he did not think of something fast. At that time, State Trooper Jason L. Brewer allegedly informed Mr. Estep that he would make sure he gets out of jail on a very low bond if he would implicate Richards and Wine in the Break-In. Mr. Estep was subsequently released on a very low Bond of $15,000 considering he had previously been convicted of the Felony Offense of Burglarizing an elderly lady’s home on three separate occasions in the recent past.

3. Through investigations and review of Court Documents along with word of mouth Trooper Brewer allegedly wanted Mr. Estep to wrongfully implicate John Richards as Mr. Richards had previously worked with a Prosecutor in shedding light on misconduct committed by members of the West Virginia State Police. Two of the WV State Troopers that Mr. Richards gave information on was Trooper Doug P. Starcher and Trooper C. J. Ellyson. Both Troopers appeared to have been idolized by Trooper Jason Brewer. Trooper Ellyson while acting as Detachment commander at the Calhoun Barracks claimed he thought evidence in a criminal case was trash and threw it away. However, Richards produced evidence to the contrary to State Investigators. Richards has since been wrongfully arrested by the West Virginia State Police on numerous bogus charges all of which resulted in Richards being found not guilty by a Chief Circuit Court Judge, a Magistrate also found Mr. Richards not guilty of bogus State Police charges. Other charges were dismissed by Magistrates and even an honest Prosecutor weight in on a wrongful arrest by dismissing charges against Richards on yet further trumped up charges filed against Richards by the West Virginia State Police agency.

4. Word of mouth also seems to reveal that Trooper Jason Brewer wanted Estep to falsely implicate David Wine, just to show Richards he had the power to arrest any of his friends. It is reported that Trooper Jason Brewer caused the arrest of Mr. Wine due to suffering from the mentality of, “Because I Can”.

5. Upon Trooper Jason Brewer securing the coerced false statement from Mr. Estep, Trooper Brewer obtained arrest warrants on all three individuals. Even though there was no corroborating evidence to tie Richards or Wine to any crime and the fact that it was clear that Mr. Estep was misrepresenting the facts of his very own one man crime spree. Richards and Wine was incarcerated on a $100,000 dollar bond each. Both Richards and Wine have pleaded not guilty to all charges and have requested the false charges be dismissed or be provided with a Jury Trial at the earliest possible date.

6. The Plea Agreement posted in this article is actually the second Plea Agreement Mr. William Willis Estep II entered into. The first plea agreement which included releasing Mr. Estep on a low bond and providing him with a plea to serve very little time. However, Mr. Estep backed out on that plea to provide false testimony on Mr. Richards and Mr. Wine. Shortly thereafter the Ritchie County Prosecuting Attorney had Mr. Estep incarcerated in order to coerce and force Mr. Estep to once again be on hand to Test-Ta-Lie in the case. After, sitting in Jail for a couple of weeks, Mr. Estep once again agreed to falsely blame John and Dave if he was released from Jail.

So here you have it folks. You have Mr. William Willis Estep II who said he knew nothing about any crimes… Then claiming maybe he did know something about numerous crimes… Then being released from Jail… Then again maybe he knew nothing about any crime… Then again being placed in Jail… Then after sitting in Jail Mr. Estep’s memory came back to him and he once again knew about crime… The only thing Mr. Estep truly knows is he is a one man crime spree who is willing to provide false testimony as directed by Rogue Ritchie County Officials in order to try and save his neck.


Ritchie County Prosecutor willfully and maliciously exercised Bad Faith in the Harrisville State Police Burglary Sham.

Core Members of the Ritchie County Corruption Investigation Team reserved a section of the Outback® Steak House in Bridgeport, WV to conduct their bi-weekly meeting on April 25, 2014.

A somewhat heated topic of discussion lead to a motion by several members to have a Staff Writer for the RitchieRailRoad website to prepared an article on Ritchie County Prosecutor misconduct regarding the West Virginia State Police Burglary Case.

Just today a draft of the article was electronically distributed to all core members for their review and input. The article will be published right here on the RitchieRailRoad and other area Truth Blogs which will further inform the public of the wrongful arrest brought about by a Prosecutor who was willfully and maliciously exercising Bad Faith the Case.

Also, our allies have secured additional evidence concerning Malicious Intent by the Prosecutor’s Office in the form of a Plea Agreement between the State and Mr. William Willis Estep II for his agreement to test-ta-lie in the State Police Burglary Case. Mr. Estep is not a RAT nor a Truthful Informant, but rather Mr. William Willis Estep II is a “Blamer” that’s right, Mr. Estep relieved himself of over a dozen Felony Charges by Blaming/Claiming and Agreeing to test-ta-lie in the State Police Burglary Case. Read the spectacular plea agreement which will be posted this Sunday evening, April 27, 2014.


Stats for RitchieRailRoad.com - Ritchie County Judicial News is getting out - WV State Police False Arrest In the News

Stats… Ritchie Rail Road


Stats for RitchieRailRoad.com – Ritchie County Judicial News is getting out – WV State Police False Arrest In the News